Madi Diaz writes with the discipline of someone who has spent years in Nashville and Los Angeles writing songs professionally: clear melodies, direct language and very little wasted motion. On her own records, she turns that craft toward feelings that are considerably less orderly, following resentment, doubt, desire and heartbreak past the point where a more conventional songwriter might clean them up.

History of a Feeling (2021), her first album for ANTI-, was the breakthrough. Produced with Andrew Sarlo and built largely around guitar, piano and voice, the record brought Diaz’s writing into unusually close focus. Pitchfork noted that her melodies were polished enough for “a far more commercial record,” while singling out her own recording of “Resentment” — previously recorded by Kesha — for hitting “so much harder.” The album established a tension that would run through her ANTI- work: formidable pop-song construction carrying emotions that remain unresolved and occasionally brutal.

Weird Faith (2024) gave that writing a fuller setting. Kacey Musgraves joined Diaz on “Don’t Do Me Good,” which earned a Grammy nomination for Best Americana Performance, while the album itself was nominated for Best Folk Album. The title track asks what it means to remain open to love after experience has taught you to be wary; “God Person” moves through religious doubt, her parents’ marriage and the patterns people inherit without necessarily understanding them.

Fatal Optimist (2025) stripped the music back again. Made with Gabe Wax and recorded mostly as Diaz alone with an acoustic guitar, it leaves very little between the listener and songs written in the immediate aftermath of emotional upheaval. Uncut called it “one of the least clichéd breakup records you’re ever likely to hear.” The starkness was deliberate: Diaz wanted to preserve the feeling of still being inside the experience rather than looking back on it after it had been resolved.

During the Fatal Optimist sessions, Diaz also recorded Enema of the Garden State, a song-for-song acoustic reworking of blink-182’s Enema of the State. Working with producer and engineer Andrew Maury in New Jersey, she used the songs as morning warm-ups, recording quickly to four-track with what she described as “no planning, no overthinking, no analyzing.” What began as a private exercise in nostalgia eventually became a full release, with proceeds benefiting the Defending Our Neighbors Fund, which provides legal assistance to immigrant families.

The 2026 deluxe edition, Fatal Optimist (UN-unplugged), shows another side of the original album. The deluxe adds reworked versions of “Hope Less,” “Heavy Metal” with Lucy Dacus and “Why’d You Have To Bring Me Flowers” with August Ponthier, plus a cover of Maren Morris' “This Is How a Woman Leaves.” Diaz described the difference as moving from the original album’s “insular raw” world toward something “not so solitary, more like lonely together.”

Start with “Resentment” from History of a Feeling, “Weird Faith” from Weird Faith, “Heavy Metal” from Fatal Optimist and “Going Away to College” from Enema of the Garden State.

+
Madi Diaz
  • Fatal Optimist LP (Clear Pink Wave)Vendor:
    Regular price
    $20.99
    Sale price
    $20.99
    Regular price
    $29.99
  • Fatal Optimist CDVendor:
    Regular price
    $11.19
    Sale price
    $11.19
    Regular price
    $13.99
  • History Of A Feeling LP (White)Vendor:
    Regular price
    $25.99
    Sale price
    $25.99
    Regular price
  • Weird Faith CDVendor:
    Regular price
    $11.19
    Sale price
    $11.19
    Regular price
    $13.99
  • Weird Faith LP (Black)Vendor:
    Regular price
    $19.19
    Sale price
    $19.19
    Regular price
    $23.99
  • History Of A Feeling CDVendor:
    Regular price
    $13.99
    Sale price
    $13.99
    Regular price
  • History Of A Feeling LP (Black)Vendor:
    Regular price
    $23.99
    Sale price
    $23.99
    Regular price
  • Fatal Optimist LP (Black)Vendor:
    Regular price
    $22.39
    Sale price
    $22.39
    Regular price
    $27.99