It is the first time that such moral rights - protecting the personality and reputation of writers and authors - have been established in a Spanish court, acknowledging an artist’s voice as his creative work. The judgement, rendered by the Appeal Court of Barcelona, also recognised that VAESA and the production company, Tandem Company Guasch, had infringed the Intellectual Property Rights of both Waits and Hans Kusters Music, Waits’ music publisher in Spain.
The commercial, for Audi cars, was originally screened in Spain in 2000. As well as having much the same melodic structure as the Tom Waits’ song ‘Innocent When You Dream’, the commercial’s music was arranged like the song and featured a Tom Waits’ vocal impersonation.
At the time of making the commercial Tandem Campany Guasch had sought permission to use Waits’ original version of ‘Innocent When You Dream’, a request he rejected. “Now they understand the words to the song better,” says Waits. “It wasn't ‘Innocent When You Scheme’ it was ‘Innocent When You Dream’.”
Waits and Hans Kusters Music won an initial court judgement in March 2004. The case then went to the Appeal Court, ultimately resulting in this month’s groundbreaking legal victory.
Tom Waits first learned about the commercial from fans when visiting Spain in the summer of 2000. Many believed it was Waits singing his own song on the commercial, even despite the fact he has always been adamant that his music will never be used for advertising purposes.
The judgement is the latest in a line of successful legal actions Waits has taken to prevent his music and image from being associated with commercial products. He has most recently filed suit against General Motors’ Opel and the advertising agency McCann Erickson in Frankfurt, Germany, for producing and broadcasting a series of car commercials that used a perfect impersonation of Waits’ singing voice. The commercials were produced in Germany and aired in Sweden, Finland, Denmark and Norway during the late winter and early spring of last year. Among other claims, the suit charges the defendants with violating Waits' moral rights under German law.
For further information, contact Anti/Epitaph Europe +31.205503838
For further legal information and a copy of the Appeal Court Judgement:
Sonsoles Riba de Olano Abogado CUATRECASAS Paseo de Gracia, 111 Barcelona 08008 0034 3 93 290 55 48 email@example.com